Why didnt the uchiha just move

Aegon Targaryen

The ''King'' of Inventors
If they weren't welcomed in konoha why not move to a new spot why choose war.

Um, they couldn't. The village forced them to move to that place. If they tried to move to another village, that would literally be defecting and they would be hunted down and killed as missing-nin.
 

Sagebee

Well-Known Member
Um, they couldn't. The village forced them to move to that place. If they tried to move to another village, that would literally be defecting and they would be hunted down and killed as missing-nin.
Why couldnt the 3rd just order they leave peacefully and no does anything to them.
 

Aegon Targaryen

The ''King'' of Inventors
Why couldnt the 3rd just order they leave peacefully and no does anything to them.

Um...because they'd be losing their most powerful clan, lmao. That's still a bad thing.

If they must lose said clan, "better" to wipe it out entirely than literally give it to another village.
 

Sagebee

Well-Known Member
Um...because they'd be losing their most powerful clan, lmao. That's still a bad thing.

If they must lose said clan, "better" to wipe it out entirely than literally give it to another village.
The 3rd has a good heart and wants peace so why not pick the option where everyone still lives if the uchiha cant coexist which I dont understand why they cant since its konoha discriminatory practices that's at fault. But if it's not an option why wouldnt the 3rd pick this route.
 

Utopia Realm

Looking for a Happy Ending....
Even though I heard it that Byakugan and Sharingan couldn't mix, if it could mix, why not offer to join the 2 clans together. Hyuugas get Red Eyeballs and Uchihas get White Eyeballs. :hm

Perhaps Hirashima could have offered the Uchiha's a chanc eat hosting a Bijuu had they backstabbed and left Madara to die in a ditch somewhere.:hm
 

Aegon Targaryen

The ''King'' of Inventors
The 3rd has a good heart and wants peace so why not pick the option where everyone still lives if the uchiha cant coexist which I dont understand why they cant since its konoha discriminatory practices that's at fault. But if it's not an option why wouldnt the 3rd pick this route.

Why would Hiruzen send a clan they already mistrust to join another village, one that might even be their enemy? They've literally just made one of their rivals stronger.

Also, Hiruzen was a jellyfish, to quote @Gunners. He made many mistakes with the Uchiha and did not even try to negotiate with them until way later.
 

DaVizWiz

Well-Known Member
Konoha was their home, most of them weren’t plotting shit behind the scenes and kind of accepted they were the mexicans (rarely given attention or considered for anything in society, kind of just there working and not complaining) of the village, and a lot of evil intention killers would have come for their Sharingan without Konoha’s asylum

There’s other issues, mainly the fact that a sour Uchiha clan no longer under the jurisdiction of Konoha could try to come back and cause problems

Also a different country getting the Uchicha is a national security issue, Konoha getting weaker and another country getting stronger (even if it were an ally, which Konoha had none at the time) isn’t something they’re going to allow without trying to kill them first, the Uchiha being narionless (at their own beckon) are much easier to murder politically and are even more dangerous than being part of another country that at least could keep them in check due to their own broad concerns

The easiest way to combat this would be to spread propaganda and use non-war means to break this kind of plan down and erase it, like threatening band leaders with prosecution while at the same time offering the others fake incentives for snitching or staying, it likely happened quite a few times but Konoha managed to crush the thought of migrating and kept most of the clan members who just wanted to stay the course and live their lives under their thumb
 
Last edited:

Yuna Jonetsu

Well-Known Member
More than anything else, it is like asking one of the two founding families of a country to leave somewhere else. :catwat
 

Aduro

Definitely not a villain.
I guess it couldn't have gone much worse than what they actually did...

Danzo and the Elders definitely would have wanted the Uchiha dead.
Shinobi take secrets very seriously and the Uchiha would have known a lot that could have been valuable to other villages. They would probably just be massacred in a different way, although if they had their own territory and Itachi and Shisui didn't turn on them, a few could slip the net.

But if the Uchiha had successfully formed an alliance, the costs of pursuing them might have been deemed too high.


I think that the main reason the Uchiha were doomed was that they didn't have any allies. Partly because their position as military police put them at a distance. Partly because they seemed to think they were too above the others to stoop so low. So its hard to believe that they could successfully defect to another village. The other village would have to put a lot of trust in the Uchiha and risk war with Konoha.
 

WorldsStrongest

Man of Miracles
Personally if I was the clan head?

Id have literally packed up my clan and straight up defected from Konoha en masse :oldshrug

The village had done nothing but fuck up the Uchiha clan and persecute them for crimes they had nothing to do with for generations straight and they were never given a fair shake.

First they got accused of being in league with Madaras attack back in the day, then again with Obitos. Both times with literally no evidence to tie them to the one maverick responsible.

So Id say "fuck this joint" and peace out.

Id have (covertly obviously) met with or otherwise messaged the one of the 4 other villages and told them of our plans, and then moved there after they agreed to take us in and fold us into the upper echelons of running the village free of any stigma. Or Id have told all 4 of the other villages in secret and then basically just see which one gives our clan the best offer basically. Then once its set in stone that wed be granted asylum and protected from Konohas hunter squads...Off wed go in the cover of goddamn night like Sasuke did if thats what itd take.

There is literally no village that would turn us away...Kumo was ready to go to fucking war over THE BYAKUGAN...And Kiri fucking worshipped the Byakugan they stole and put into Ao...The Sharingan is a whole other beast and the entire world knows that. We would be welcomed with open arms to any village and theyd be all but begging us to move in in fact.

See how Konoha gets along without their best clan theyve walked all over for generations when it plays for another team.

Personally Id join Kumo. Imho they have the best looking village in terms of geography, and are pretty clearly the strongest village after Minatos death due to Killer Bee. Throw the Uchihas in the mix? Including the likes of Itachi and Shisui allowed to train and grow older and stronger in the safety of another village? Easily the best village.

Also...Kumo babes...Delicious



So yeah...Id straight up relocate my entire damn clan and declare loyalty to a entirely separate village

Konoha was gonna kill us all anyway so the idea theyd be salty over the loss of us is just hilarious.
 
Top Bottom