Is it Hate or Justice for Sasuke to kill Itachi?

Willy927

Willy927

Lonliness..BE My Str
Sasuke mentioned alot about Hate and stuff and how his hate is going to kill Itachi, but face it, Itachi commited crime which is unforgivable to Sasuke. If Itachi went to court, he would be charge for genocide and probably would be sentence to death penalty in the most painful way.

Instead of just saying Sasuke is a hater, he was serving justice.

However, Kish might try to write a twisted story and say Itachi isn't the real bad guy and somehow Sasuke killed the wrong person.

(That would drive me nuts.)
 
It is Hate pure Hate

I hope he doesn't do that but I think that Itachi will still die but in an honorable way like a true shinobi , but in terms of justices Sasuke left justice behind the moment he went to Oro's and abandon his morals (I'm not a Sasuke hater BTW just sating whats true) and attack his comrades (not that I blame him they were kinda asking for it) but he is just out for vengeance now but that was his aim from the beginning so yeah.
 
If Sasuke killed the 'wrong one', it isn’t his fault. Itachi clearly set it up that way. As far as what it is- it’s pay back from way back.
 
...Itachi wasn't killed by Sasuke... the way it seems right now, it was more of a suicide from Itachis side.

I mean, come on, if there was no downside to summon Susano'o like, for example, it's killing you off bit by bit, why keep it hidden till you're on the verge of death anyway ( i mean, apart from story structure)?
I highly doubt anyone could escape it if it was full powered, so even then, it would remain a secret jutsu.

As of this moment, Sasuke only survived the battle, but he didn't finish Itachi off by his own hands, which is probably why Sasuke is going to end up being emo again for not killing him with his own hands...

We can't loose emo Sasuke, else the manga would be over oo
 
both
but no one in uchiha clan will blame him

cuz he kill the traitor of the clan.....I'm sure if it is not sasuke....the uchiha police force will do it.....I bet sasuke will get a promotion of what he does if the police force still exist
 
I think it's a combination of both. Sasuke's hate is definitely his motivation, but can anyone say he isn't justified in killing the person who murdered his family?

I think Kishi might have set up Shikamaru and Team 10's revenge to sort of compare and contrast with Sasuke's revenge. They took revenge in the same way Sasuke did, but they did it together and didn't compromise Konoha's ideals. So Kishi might be trying to say it's not Sasuke's revenge that's the problem but what he did to obtain power for his revenge (going to Orochimaru and abandoning his friends).

Basically, I think Sasuke's hate and revenge are somewhat justified (understandable is a better word), but what he did to obtain his revenge was not.
 
Itachi wants Sasuke to kill him. So Sasuke can become strong enough to defeat Tobi/Madara But Sasuke didn't gain MS like Itachi had hoped.
 
Revenge and justice are not the same thing. Batman has taught us that! However, Naruto's world isn't ours, their justice depends on the greater good and a villages' best interests. So, Sasuke isn't doing anything wrong, arguably he's honouring his clan by condemning Itachi's actions. It's worthy of justification, but is it respectable, the way he turned on his friends? That's what's so bittersweet and interesting to me.
 
its justice, and hate, the hate that sasuke feels is part of a desire for revenge, in this case, his revenge is justice, so, its both :D
 
Sasuke is simply following the path of being a tool that will do anything to accomplish his mission (ie kill Itachi) which is actually a normal for a ninja. You can't blame a ninja for acting the way they are supposted to after all.

It's Naruto and the others that are wierd from the standard philosphy of the ninja world not the other way around.

We shouldn't judge him by our worlds standards becuse we don't live in the same reality that they do.

Ultimately what Sasuke did was Justice as it was for the greater good. What ever harm he brought to his friends is minimized by the gain they have recived from his efforts from taking down several rouge s rank ninja that where a threat to them, to helping them grow stronger.
 
Lets be fair here for Sasuke too, remember Kakashi told him to forget about Itachi and not go after him? Sasuke did not do anything wrong to Konoha. All he wanted to do is to leave konoha and get power to kill off Itachi which Naruto tried to stop. He did not support Orochimaru into kill anyone, or even killed anyone, as far as i know in the Manga, Deidara suicided, Itachi killed himself, and there are also hints that Oro may still be alive.

Sasuke wanted justice and if the village wouldn't help him achieve that, how is he wrong from trying to do it in his own ways.
 
You're assuming it can't be both.

I would say if the family of one of Jeffrey Dahmers victims had been the ones to beat him to death, that would be both justice and hatred.

In this case its both.
 
how many ppl in the world wanted to see osama's death and suffering since he was the one that planned the terrorist attack that killed so many ppl?

if one person kill someone that you care about, you can hate this person, and want justice at the same time


want to kill someone and hate can be the twisted part of the justice
 
Willy927 said:
Sasuke mentioned alot about Hate and stuff and how his hate is going to kill Itachi, but face it, Itachi commited crime which is unforgivable to Sasuke. If Itachi went to court, he would be charge for genocide and probably would be sentence to death penalty in the most painful way.

Instead of just saying Sasuke is a hater, he was serving justice.

However, Kish might try to write a twisted story and say Itachi isn't the real bad guy and somehow Sasuke killed the wrong person.

(That would drive me nuts.)
Click to expand...

Sasuke won't do it, he's not like that.

But if he did, here's what I'd say:

It's the same "justice" that Shikamaru gave to a defeated, helpless Hidan out of hate and revenge.:)

Will I agree with Sasuke? No, not personally.

BUT, since Kishimoto AND this forum all said that it was just fine for Shikamaru to torture and kill a helpless, defenseless Hidan back in 339, I will not fault Sasuke for doing what apparently "heroes" are allowed to do in this story. And it would be pretty hypocritical of those who clapped Shikamaru on the back for what he did to Hidan, to now throw stones at Sasuke if he did the same.
 
Last edited:
Because Sasuke became a traitor it is hate. Had he stayed loyal to Konoha and done it as a governmentally sanctioned act it would have been justice.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom