Dumbledore(prime),Voldemort,and Grindelwald(prime) Vs Gandalf the white

Status
Not open for further replies.

gtw1983

Will Rep for Food!! ;)
Of the three Dumbledore prime would be the strongest since even the old version could have beat voldemort without horcruxes.

I think Grindelwald would have been next in strength since dumbledore Said at end of DH that in his prime Grindelwald was a "shade" less skilled than himself.

And last but not least voldemort enters the battle with all his powers except the use of his soul containers.

they all three fight Gandalf at once in a battle to the death.
 
Gandalf appears in a flash of light,all three wands ignite.

Gandalf then proceeds to MAIARSTOMP!

Only Voldy might have survived with horcruxes but since you took those out...
 
No :zaru

It's still a stomp unless you want to give me reasons of how any one in harry potter stand chance against a Balrog

That's not really fair though, Gandalf used the fact that they were on a bridge over a huge ass pit to his advantage. Not saying that HarryPotter combatants can take this, but that that isn't a very compelling argument. Granted, I only watched the movie rendition of LotR, if Gandalf took him out differently in the books then I stand corrected.
 
yeah...good point!

I wasn't fully aware of White Gandalfs powers so maybe the grey form would be a better match.

Gandalf the grey defeated a balrog in single combat there is no way any HP wizard can do a feat even close to that.

That's not really fair though, Gandalf used the fact that they were on a bridge over a huge ass pit to his advantage. Not saying that HarryPotter combatants can take this, but that that isn't a very compelling argument. Granted, I only watched the movie rendition of LotR, if Gandalf took him out differently in the books then I stand corrected.

The Balrog recovered completely from that after 3 days and Gndalf then fort it for days none stop on top of the highest peaks of the misty mountins until he struck it down.

Most of the real fight never took place the bridge of kazadum
 
That's not really fair though, Gandalf used the fact that they were on a bridge over a huge ass pit to his advantage. Not saying that HarryPotter combatants can take this, but that that isn't a very compelling argument. Granted, I only watched the movie rendition of LotR, if Gandalf took him out differently in the books then I stand corrected.

He then chased the Balrog all the way to a mountain and owned it with a sword.

Watch the movie again.
 
Am I the only one that notes that Gandalf beat a Balrog in melee combat?

Impressive feat? Hell yes.

Does it really matter when he's facing three wizards that aren't going to be dumb enough to get anywhere near that close? Hell no.

Please, please be aware that I'm not trying to argue for the Potter crew. I've never read LOTR, so I'm not knowledgeable enough to properly gauge this fight.

Just saying that a melee fight has little impact on a wizard's duel.
 
Am I the only one that notes that Gandalf beat a Balrog in melee combat?

Impressive feat? Hell yes.

Does it really matter when he's facing three wizards that aren't going to be dumb enough to get anywhere near that close? Hell no.

Please, please be aware that I'm not trying to argue for the Potter crew. I've never read LOTR, so I'm not knowledgeable enough to properly gauge this fight.

Just saying that a melee fight has little impact on a wizard's duel.

:facepalm

He didn't just beat the Balrog is melee combat. He freaking channeled lightning into his sword to stab to finish the Balrog.

The second the match starts, Gandalf just ignites their wands. Seriously. That is how strong Gandalf is.
 
:facepalm

He didn't just beat the Balrog is melee combat. He freaking channeled lightning into his sword to stab to finish the Balrog.

The second the match starts, Gandalf just ignites their wands. Seriously. That is how strong Gandalf is.
I don't see what the 'facepalm' is for, my friend.

I was merely pointing out that a sword vs. demon encounter bears little comparison to a wizard vs. three wizard encounter. I don't see that as being hard to understand nor hard to agree with.
 
Am I the only one that notes that Gandalf beat a Balrog in melee combat?

Impressive feat? Hell yes.

Does it really matter when he's facing three wizards that aren't going to be dumb enough to get anywhere near that close? Hell no.

Please, please be aware that I'm not trying to argue for the Potter crew. I've never read LOTR, so I'm not knowledgeable enough to properly gauge this fight.

Just saying that a melee fight has little impact on a wizard's duel.

Gandalf Broke Saurmons staff without even going near him. Saurmon would of shit on the Harry Potter verse easy. For Gandalf to break his staff is amazing power and I don't see he couldn't just break all the wizards wands, without the wands they are shit.

Also do you remember Gandalf the Grey and Saurmons fight? If Gandalf fought any of them like that they would die in seconds.
 
I dont give a damn if Gandalf meeled a Greek Titan, he's not stomping Voldy.

Teleport and Killing curse ends this. Then Voldy proceeds to kill Dumbledore.
 
I don't see what the 'facepalm' is for, my friend.

I was merely pointing out that a sword vs. demon encounter bears little comparison to a wizard vs. three wizard encounter. I don't see that as being hard to understand nor hard to agree with.

Balrogs are basically wizards as well. They to perform magic.
 
I dont give a damn if Gandalf meeled a Greek Titan, he's not stomping Voldy.

Teleport and Killing curse ends this. Then Voldy proceeds to kill Dumbledore.

Gandalfs a spiritual entity since when did killing curse work on ghosts and spirits
 
Grindelwald is rather useless in this match- we have no feats for him, only the knowledge that he was the last great dark wizard before Voldemort and that he was on the level of Dumbledore (or rather below, since Dumbledore managed to defeat him while he had the Elder Wand).

Here's the deal.

HPverse wizards are useless without their wands.

Gandalf the White shattered Saruman's staff easily. Saruman is far greater than any HPverse wizard.

In The Hobbit Gandalf had the power to incinerate people.

Gandalf shatters all three wizard's wands. Then he incinerates them.

GG.
 
Gandalf The White casually stopped an enchanted elven arrow,a dwarven axe and superheated Anduril,an elven relic sword that would piss on the sword of Griffindor.
 
It's Gandalf and not Balrog we're talking about.

I know that I was saying that no Harry potter wizard has a feat that can compare to Gandalf defeating a giant flaming demon that can smite entire armies.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom