BM VS Rooftop 5

Who wins?


  • Total voters
    26

Heart Over Blade

Enlightened Despot
Locaton: Onigashima Rooftop
Distance: 15M



This is the original Rooftop 5 with pre-aCoC Luffy, Zoro, Awakening restricted Law + Kidd, and Killer.

Both G5 Luffy and Kaidou have passed their tests against this team in recent threads. Does BM defeat them too or do they drop her into the ocean like the RT4 minus Luffy almost did?

I think they drop her into the ocean. BM only survived last time because they didn't follow through on preventing her homie from saving her. Zoro already had his bones broken for that feat and wasn't in Asura. Killer was attacking Napoleon with generic swings, and Kid didn't use his higher end techs. Law could've spammed more Takt and used bigger boulders. Her homies are also vulnerable to getting Shambled to the edge of Law's island sized room so they don't even have to deal with the homies this time. Luffy didn't even participate.
 
Last edited:

YonkoDrippy

Well-Known Member
they can BFR her like Kidd and Law did, but they can’t KO her.

Big Mom is near equal to Kaido who already took on this team + the scabbards + Yamato and G5 Luffy and is still fighting with no issue.

Eventually Big Mom would put them down in an all out battle
 

Heart Over Blade

Enlightened Despot
BM's lack of mobility really hurts her here. Her homies are weak enough to get Shambled as we've already seen and they can't use haki to prevent it. That's why even the three homie fused Misery got one shotted by a nameless swing from an exhausted Law. What sent her falling off Onigashima from the rooftop last time was a combo from just two of them, Kid's Repel and a single Takt from Law. While BM has her bigger Mom form, Kid's Repel sent her base form flying pretty easily. Punk Hazard Law has already shown the ability to use Takt on masses greater than the medium sized boulder he used on BM, and Law could throw them in succession. This time the 5 of them could gang on her without fighting her homies to make it easier.
 

Corax

Well-Known Member
If BFR is allowed R5. In more neutral battleground BM should win around high at worst. Without aCoC and awakening not much they can do to her.
 

Heart Over Blade

Enlightened Despot
If BFR is allowed R5.
It is allowed. It's the same battleground she fought the RT5 last time. She ate a DF, she has to deal with the drawbacks like everyone else who ate a DF and gained power.

But I would say merely removing her from the rooftop isn't a win. They have to drop her into water or lava to call it a true victory.
 

Amol

Chief of Wisdom
Rooftop SNs doesn't have enough attack power to hurt her seriously.


Luffy with his AdCoC can but not too extreme degree. Zoro had no control over how AdCoC while Law and Kid has no Awakening here.

It should be good fight but she would win nonetheless.
 

gunchar

Well-Known Member
BFR is a realistic chance, but without Oda's bad writing this would be an uphill battle for the restricted RT5.
 

Empathy

Last edited a moment ago
Luffy and Zoro both looked stronger than Law and Kid on the rooftop, and we know that the latter duo didn’t get any stronger between the rooftop and fighting Big Mom alone. Those two alone would make it close, but with the added high tier support, they win for sure.
 
Last edited:

gunchar

Well-Known Member
Luffy and Zoro both looked stronger than Law and Kid on the rooftop, and we know that the latter duo didn’t get any stronger between the rooftop and fighting Big Mon alone. Those two alone would make it close, but with the added high tier support, they win for sure.
Bruh..., Luffy and Zoro only looked stronger cause Law and Kid were holding back the whole time, did you even read the manga? Law and Kid even with all their PIS + the plot bombs wouldn't have accomplished anything against BM without Awakenings, and even just Law's Puncture Wille alone was already more impressive than all at the earlier point shown attacks of the RT5 put together.
 

Empathy

Last edited a moment ago
Bruh..., Luffy and Zoro only looked stronger cause Law and Kid were holding back the whole time, did you even read the manga? Law and Kid even with all their PIS + the plot bombs wouldn't have accomplished anything against BM without Awakenings, and even just Law's Puncture Wille alone was already more impressive than all at the earlier point shown attacks of the RT5 put together.

They weren’t holding back, they just didn’t use their awakening trump cards yet, because they didn’t have any opportunity to, and it wouldn’t have affected the outcome in any meaningful way at that point. They’d just have exhausted their stamina early and then been unable to defend themselves. Their awakenings aren’t forms that would offer any stat boosts across the board; just attacks that do a lot of damage at the expense of a ton of their stamina.

Big Mom tanked multiple Puncture Willes on top of a ton of other damage, and could still fight. I don’t think it’s necessarily any stronger than aCoC Ashura, and likely would’ve produced a similar effect (injured one of the Yonkou pretty badly, but then they’d still be in fighting condition and would just finish off the user). Luffy and Zoro had Law and Kid pretty clearly outclassed in most physical stats and Haki. Fights in OP boil down to more than just using your trump card.
 

Corax

Well-Known Member
It is allowed. It's the same battleground she fought the RT5 last time. She ate a DF, she has to deal with the drawbacks like everyone else who ate a DF and gained power.

But I would say merely removing her from the rooftop isn't a win. They have to drop her into water or lava to call it a true victory.
Yes,but they did so in canon and Kaido had to help her if I am correct.
 

Chip Skylark

Pretty Flacko Sr.
She only loses because she's such a ditz. They would've knocked her into the ocean if not for Kaido's interference, and that doesn't change in this scenario. Especially with Luffy now being able to focus on just her.

Like others said, they can't k.o. her but they can certainly BFR her.
 
Top Bottom