I know you want to try to be as correct and accurate as possible in matters like these, but sometimes there are cases when things can go either way or in any direction without a strict single mandatory one.
This is how I'm currently viewing all of life, reality, and existence in general.
you said that in the OBD that Peach vs. Zelda would get the same answers in general consensus as Death Battle's verdict. Yet in the latest Peach vs. Zelda thread we have here, much more people seem to be saying that Zelda should have won.
Guess your theory is proven bunk, hmmm? Or maybe it would have actually been true back before Death Battle existed.
Don't take it personally. I'm just trying to play the Devil's Advocate.